Top 3 Types of Roofs and How to Find the Best Type of Roof for You

If you are looking for a full roof replacement, now’s the time to make a decision on the type of roof that you want. Roofers around the country offer various materials based on their client’s preference and style. At Duluth Roofing, our top three sellers are asphalt shingles, metal, and cedar shake. Each of these types of roofs have pros and cons that you need to consider before making your decision.


1. Asphalt Shingles – Simple, Economical, Familiar


When looking for the best type of roof for your home, the most affordable and most popular option is asphalt shingles. Drive through the majority of neighborhoods in America, and you’ll find shingle roofs in a variety of colors and styles. Asphalt shingles can be used in any type of climate. Because of its ease of installation and affordability, the majority of roofers recommend it to their clients. 





While common and economical, asphalt shingles do have a few faults. For instance, out of all the various types of roofing materials, asphalt is not very environmentally friendly. Asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan than other types of roofs, and they are more likely to obtain storm damage than other more durable options. When considering asphalt shingles, it’s important to consider how long you plan on living in the house and whether you want the roof to outlast your stay. 


2. Metal Roofing – Environmentally-Friendly, Long-lasting, Durable


Metal roofing is growing in popularity due to its environmentally-friendly properties and long lifespan. As steel mills continue to evolve, there are more textures and colors of metal roofing available to homeowners. Metal is very durable and can withstand inclement weather with minimal damage. For homes located in the southern United States, metal roofing reflects heat away from the home, which could help save as much as 40% in energy costs.


The metal can be recycled as well and is a sustainable option. For homeowners who value roofs with long lifespans, metal roofs can last up to 50 years. A few potential pitfalls with metal roofing involve installation and fixes. Your roofer must be qualified and knowledgeable about metal roof installation. Poor installations can lead to leaks. While metal roofs are more difficult to damage, they are also more difficult to repair. If your asphalt shingles are damaged in a storm, it’s usually a quick fix. But if your metal roof gets damaged, it’s a more costly repair that usually involves replacing an entire panel. 


3. Cedar Shake – Trendy, Unique, Natural


Have you heard of cedar shake roofing? Cedar shake roofing is a unique, striking material used to create a strong aesthetic. Cedar shake is completely natural and recyclable. While it’s more expensive than metal roofing, it is easier to repair. Similar to asphalt shingles, cedar shake can be patched rather than completely replaced. If you want a natural and outdoorsy look to your home, take a look at cedar shake. However, be cautious if you live in an area with fire risks, as the material is much more flammable than asphalt or metal. 


While cedar shake roofs are beautiful and unique, they also have the shortest lifespan. But, cedar shake is also more durable than asphalt shingles, so your roof will require less maintenance over the years. If you are looking for a natural look and feel that makes your home stand out, cedar shake might be a great choice for you.


Which type of roof is best for me?


As you’ve read, each of the above types of roofs have positives and negatives. So how do you choose the best type of roof for your home? We’ve compiled a short list of questions to ask yourself to help you with this decision.


  • What is my budget?

If you are building a new home or if you are looking to replace an existing roof, think about your budget before you get attached to a specific style of roof. Asphalt shingles are the most affordable option for homeowners on a budget. If a budget is not a concern, you can look into more expensive options like cedar shake.


  • Do I have a flat or low sloped roof?

Flat roofing systems are a bit different from common sloped roofs. If you have a flat or minimally sloped roof, look into EPDM rubber roofing. It’s one of Duluth Roofing’s bestsellers! EPDM rubber roofing lasts just as long as metal roofs and is extremely durable. While most commonly used on commercial buildings, it can also be installed on residential homes. 


  • What is my aesthetic? 

Take a look at the homes in your neighborhood. Do you want your home to stand out from the rest? Or do you want to align with the homes around yours? If you want your home to have a unique aesthetic, you might want to consider metal or cedar shake. 


  • What’s my climate?

For homes in the north, snow is an important weather component that you need to consider when choosing a roof option. Metal roofs have more trouble with snow loads and need to be treated with more care and caution in the winter months. If you live in a dry climate, cedar shake could be more of a fire hazard in the dry months. 


  • How long will I live in my home?

If you plan to live in your home for 30 or more years, you might want to consider a roof with a longer lifespan, like metal. If you’re only planning on living in your home for the next 10 years, asphalt shingles are a cheaper option to consider for more short-term housing.


Deciding what the best type of roof is for your home is an important decision. Talk to your roofing professional if you still have questions. While our number one seller is asphalt shingles, that doesn’t mean that it should be your automatic selection. Your home is a reflection of your style and personality, and your roof should be no different!


Do you have questions about how to choose your roofing material? We are happy to help! Feel free to send us a question on our contact page. 


Roofing company
11 Nov, 2021
Whether getting a roof replacement or simple repairs, discover four reasons to share an insurer's roofing estimate with your roofing company. Learn more!
winter roof protection
19 Oct, 2021
Discover our five essential tips for roof protection in cold weather and how to prevent damaging ice dams. Prevention steps are vital. Learn more!
roofing contractor
29 Sep, 2021
Before you hire someone to work on your roof, here are the top 5 risks of working with cheap roofing contractors and how to avoid them. Learn more!
23 Aug, 2021
Have you ever asked the question, “When does a roof need to be replaced?” If so, you’re not alone. Many homeowners wonder about when to replace a roof. When it comes to roof damage, you have to look at roof repairs versus a full roof replacement . If you are concerned about a leaky or damaged roof, read more about our tips for determining the extent of your potential roof deterioration. 1. Check for debris in your yard after a storm. Severe weather is the most common cause of roof repairs . Depending on where you live in the country, you could potentially experience heavy snows, hurricanes, tornadoes, severe thunderstorms, and hail. All of these types of weather conditions can damage your roof. We always tell our clients to take stock of any debris that they find in their yard after a strong storm. If you have an asphalt shingle roof, check to see if there are any missing shingles lying in your yard. Roof repairs versus a roof replacement varies between different types of roofs . Most damage on an asphalt roof can be repaired by a roofing company, which is considerably less expensive than a roof replacement. For other types of roofs like metal, you might have to choose a full roof replacement depending on the extent of the damage.
23 Jul, 2021
How often do roofs need to be replaced? If you’ve owned your house for years or if you’ve just purchased a new home, you might be asking this question. This blog will help outline the different roof lifespans depending on roof material. Keeping track of your roof’s age is important to maintain the integrity of your home. In this post, our team at Duluth Roofing provides information on warning signs of a damaged roof. What is your Roof Lifespan? The lifespan of a roof depends on the type of material used . More economical options, like asphalt shingles, have a shorter roof lifespan than a more expensive material like metal. In our recent blog post, we discussed the top three types of roofing material and how to choose the best option for your home. For residential houses, the top three options are asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and cedar shake. If you have a commercial building or flat top roof, EPDM rubber roofing is a long-lasting, low maintenance option. Lifespans of Popular Roofs  Asphalt Shingles – 20 to 25 years Metal Roofs – 50+ years Cedar Shake – 30+ years EPDM Rubber Roofs – 50+ years How to Find Out the Age of a Roof When you buy a home, one of the first things you need to find out is the roof age. If a previous homeowner replaced the roof, ask the realtor to find out the year that the roof replacement occurred. If there are no records of a roof replacement , here are options for determining the remaining lifespan of a roof. Obtain the Building Permit Go to the city hall in your jurisdiction. Ask the clerk to see the building permit on file for your home. Find the year that the building permit was issued to determine the age of a roof. Visual Survey by a Professional If the building permit is unclear about the age of your roof or the records no longer exist, contact your local roofing contractor to conduct a visual survey of your roof in order to estimate the age. To ensure the safety of your home and overall integrity of your roof, the National Roofing Contractors Association recommends hiring a professional to conduct a roof inspection twice a year. Why Do Roof Lifespans and Roof Replacements Matter? If you don’t keep track of the age of your roof and schedule a full roof replacement when needed, you can face severe consequences. The primary purpose of a roof is to protect everything beneath it, like your family members and possessions. If a roof is unstable or damaged, you could have water damage or framing instability. A leaky roof can lead to ceiling and drywall rot and potential flooding in severe weather. Your roof is the most important aspect of your home, so it’s vital to prioritize its upkeep. Roof Damage to Watch For That Could Require a Roof Replacement Sometimes, you must replace or repair a roof before the end of its lifespan. As a roof ages, the material wears out and could become unstable. If you own an asphalt shingle house, watch for curling shingles and missing granules . Both are signs of an aging roof. For more severe cases of roof damage, watch for any signs of water in the attic or drywall. If you notice soggy insulation or wet spots on the ceiling, call your local roofing company. For homes in cold weather climates, keep an eye out for ice dams that could indicate roof ventilation issues. raph
Share by: